Tuesday, January 22, 2013
Heart of Grizzly Man
When examining Timothy Treadwell's experiences in the Alaskan Katmai National Park and Preserve, I noticed his constant decent into madness. Throughout his 13 summers in the Park he seemed to get increasingly obsessed with the bears and the idea that their enemy was society. Whether it was Herzag's intention to progressivly make Treadwell seem more and more unhinged, or merely because of Timothy's lack of exposure to people, over time Treadwell lost a sense of human reality. To me, it was almost reminiscent of Joseph Conrad's Novella, Heart of Darkness. In the Novella, the setting- the river - acted as the vehicle for Kurtz and Marlow's transformation from an operating human in society to an animal, a beast. Similarly, Treadwell's expeditions and loneliness seemed to drive him into extreme paranoia and slight psychosis over "intruders". Intruders that is, any person who came into the park was in Timothy's mind was there to harm the animals. Not to say that some of the people actually were, but a majority, like the park service, were there to protect both the people and animals. Inevitably, Treadwell deemed himself the "protector" of the bears, foxes and all the animals he loved so dearly. This man, Treadwell, who used to teach children through his melodramatic and quirky mannerisms about his fascination with bears, undoubtedly, became crazed with the power and feeling of uncivilized living, exactly like Kurtz and Marlo's savageness towards the end of the river/book. Although Treadwell did beleive in harmony, what confounded me was that he overlooked that in humans, like when he attacked the Airline employee in his journal saying "How much I hate the peoples world." As if Timothy himself was no longer a human, or a civilized one at that. But one thing is for certain, his installation of power over the bears was through respect, he would have done anything for those bears, even willingly give up his life. He loved them. Kurtz, on the other hand, ruled over his bestial natives by establishing fear alongside his power and murdered many of his people. Therefore, Treadwell's decent into "madness" was based on a belief that all living things are innately good, differing from Kurtz's station that was barbarous and displayed an idea that everything was innately evil.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

Your evaluation of the film was very intriguing, comparing it to The Heart of Darkness. Your indepth assessment of Treadwell's mental stability was also very well put. His paranoia was caused by loneliness, leading to him becoming uncivilized and at some points, savage towards intruders. I would have to disagree with you on the basis that his madness was based on his belief that "all living things are innately good." I believe that he knew there were evil things in the world. Sometimes he may have wanted to believe that they were good, but he knew that they truly were evil, such as poachers and anyone who set out to disrupt nature. I liked how you dubbed him as protector over the animals, more so than the park rangers. He may have been crazy, but he had a good heart.
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed your view on Treadwell's adventures. I had focused more on his work with the bears and what he was trying to accomplish with his work, but your in-depth view on how he lost his humanity through his works brought a new realization to my understanding of the film.
ReplyDelete